Cover by Annie Rodrigue

EMG-Zine Entrance
Printed Anthologies
Free Download of Volume 1!

September 2008

September 2008 -- Blades

Gallery

Columns

  • Behind the Art:
    Working with Multi-media
  • EMG News:
    September Newsness
  • Artist Spotlight:
    Lee Brown Coye (1907-1981)
  • Myths and Symbols:
    The Quintessential Blade
  • Wombat Droppings:
    Doing the Gallery Thing

    Features

  • How to Practice Cyberfunded Creativity

    Fiction

  • Poem: Lady of the Pond

    Comics

  • Falheria: Blades
  • Tomb of the King: Kelsar, Part 2


    Staff
    Search EMG-Zine
    Contact
    Archives

    EMG-Zine Mailing List:
    Name:
    E-mail:

    Or Support us with a subscription or anthology purchase!
  • The Quintessential Blade
    Myths and Symbols
    by Marina Bonomi

    Blades are a strong presence in human history. From flint scraping knives of the Stone Age, to ancient Chinese ritual axes and meso-American obsidian knives, to the Roman gladium, Viking axe, table knives, Indian kriss, Bowie knife… the list is endless. But in the world of fantasy (and really science fiction too) one single family of blades truly is under the spotlight: the swords.

    From The Sword of Shannara to Robert Jordan’s Callandor (the sword that isn’t a sword); from the many retelling of the Arthurian legend with the sword in the stone and Excalibur (yes, the two aren’t originally one and the same) to Elendil’s Narsil that, re-forged for Aragorn as Anduril, bears witness to his right as legitimate heir to the kingdom of Gondor, to the Jedis' signature laser blades, swords in fantasy and SF have an archetypal role as important as that of any of the ‘speaking characters’. From where does this emphasis come?

    Quite simply, from history and ancient literature.

    Thanks to movies and other media, we all have at least a passing familiarity with the traditions pertaining the main sword of the samurai, the katana (1), although it became the signature samurai weapon only as late as the 15th-16th century. What is possibly less widely known is that the sword has at least as much tradition and symbolism in ancient Europe.

    The historian Jordanes, in his De origine actibusque Getarum (On the Origin and the Deeds of Goths) written in 551, quotes the 5th century historian Priscus about a chance finding that very likely was a pivotal point in history:

    "When a certain shepherd beheld one heifer of his flock limping and could find no cause for this wound, he anxiously followed the trail of blood and at length came to a sword it had unwittingly trampled while nibbling the grass. He dug it up and took it straight to Attila. He rejoiced at this gift and, being ambitious, thought he had been appointed ruler of the whole world, and that through the sword of Mars supremacy in all wars was assured to him.” (2)

    The attribution to Mars, of course, is due to the Roman habit of identifying local deities with the names of their Roman counterparts. Here already the sword has a double aspect as an actual weapon and a tangible sign of divine favour.

    The Hungarian burial sites of another barbaric nation, the Lombards (or Longobards) offer interesting elements at this regard. In the necropolis that have been found and studied, only the harimann (free man who had been assigned land in exchange for military duties) was buried with the full complement of weapons: sword, spear and shield (and often with his horse as well, much in the fashion of the literary Rohirrim). The free man (faramann) was buried with his spear, whereas the semi-free (haldii) were supporting troops, buried with bow and arrows. It is curious to note that a distinctive implement of the wife of an harimann was the so called ‘weaver’s blade’ or ‘weaver’s sword’: a blunt blade (usually 50 to 55 centimetres in length) used in weaving to press the newly laid weft against the fabric already made, much like a reed does in our looms.

    So, quite early we find traces of the sword as a special weapon, the trademark of the professional warrior, so to speak. In a short while the sword also became one of the main emblems of royalty, visibly marking the king as the foremost warrior and defender of the land, and stressing, as symbol of justice, the right and duty of the king to provide justice to his subjects.

    The apex in the symbolic history of the sword, though, was the Age of Chivalry. Even though in warfare the main weapon of the knight was the spear, the sword acquired an even stronger symbolic value. In the literature of the Middle Ages, we find swords that are given names and seem to possess a will of their own; swords that, infixed with stones or anvils or tree-trunks, can be extracted and wielded only by a designated hero; swords that shatter when used against right and justice, thus condemning their owner; shattered swords that can be re-forged only for their legitimate heir; and swords that resist their wielder’s attempt to break them, even for the best of reasons, as happens with Durendal in the ‘Song of Roland’:

    CLXXI

    Then Rollant feels that he has lost his sight,
    Climbs to his feet, uses what strength he might;
    In all his face the colour is grown white.
    In front of him a great brown boulder lies;
    Whereon ten blows with grief and rage he strikes;
    The steel cries out, but does not break outright;
    And the count says: "Saint Mary, be my guide
    Good Durendal, unlucky is your plight!
    I've need of you no more; spent is my pride!
    We in the field have won so many fights,
    Combating through so many regions wide
    That Charles holds, whose beard is hoary white!
    Be you not his that turns from any in flight!
    A good vassal has held you this long time;
    Never shall France the Free behold his like."

    CLXXII

    Rollant hath struck the sardonyx terrace;
    The steel cries out, but broken is no ways.
    So when he sees he never can it break,
    Within himself begins he to complain:
    "Ah! Durendal, white art thou, clear of stain!
    Beneath the sun reflecting back his rays!
    In Moriane was Charles, in the vale,
    When from heaven God by His angel bade
    Him give thee to a count and capitain;
    Girt thee on me that noble King and great.
    I won for him with thee Anjou, Bretaigne,
    And won for him with thee Peitou, the Maine,
    And Normandy the free for him I gained,
    Also with thee Provence and Equitaigne,
    And Lumbardie and all the whole Romaigne,
    I won Baivere, all Flanders in the plain,
    Also Burguigne and all the whole Puillane,
    Costentinnople, that homage to him pays;
    In Saisonie all is as he ordains;
    With thee I won him Scotland, Ireland, Wales,
    England also, where he his chamber makes;
    Won I with thee so many countries strange
    That Charles holds, whose beard is white with age!
    For this sword's sake sorrow upon me weighs,
    Rather I'd die, than it mid pagans stay.
    Lord God Father, never let France be shamed!"

    CLXXIII

    Rollant his stroke on a dark stone repeats,
    And more of it breaks off than I can speak.
    The sword cries out, yet breaks not in the least,
    Back from the blow into the air it leaps.
    Destroy it can he not; which when he sees,
    Within himself he makes a plaint most sweet.
    "Ah! Durendal, most holy, fair indeed!
    Relics enough thy golden hilt conceals:
    Saint Peter's Tooth, the Blood of Saint Basile,
    Some of the Hairs of my Lord, Saint Denise,
    Some of the Robe, was worn by Saint Mary.
    It is not right that pagans should thee seize,
    For Christian men your use shall ever be.
    Nor any man's that worketh cowardice!
    Many broad lands with you have I retrieved
    Which Charles holds, who hath the great white beard;
    Wherefore that King so proud and rich is he." (3)

    In the 11th and 12th centuries, the European sword acquired its distinctive cross shape. It was not rare then to have relics enclosed in the pommel or the hilt; and often the sword, when there was need, could be infixed in the ground as substitute of a ritual cross. With the birth of the Christian knightly ideal, all elements pertaining to the knight (armour, weapon and clothing) acquired a strong symbolic meaning. So, for instance the two cutting edges of the European sword are meant, one, to strike in defence of the faith, and the other in protection of the poor and defenceless, while the sword itself, strong but not brittle, requiring constant care to keep its edge and its polish, became the symbol of the knight’s soul.

    In the Montesiepi Chapel in Tuscany, a real Sword in the Stone can still be seen: the sword of Saint Galgano. (4)

    Tradition has it that Galgano Guidotti (1148-1181) was a knight, and wasted his youth in revels and prideful acts of force. At one point, disillusioned and disgusted by the emptiness of his life, he decided to retire to the hill of Montesiepi, living as an hermit. As a sign of penitence and renunciation to violence, he took his sword and infixed it in a rock near his dwelling, were it can be seen to this day.

    The sword was broken by a vandal in the ’60s and damaged again in 1991. Restoration works originated the rumor that it was a fake. In 2001, though, the sword was inspected with the help of the University of Siena and some fragments were analyzed in the laboratories of the Universities of Padua and Pavia. The results said that the metal showed no traces of modern alloys, and the composition is compatible with metal from the Middle Ages. The weapon is in a style used in the 12th century ( X.a of the Oakenscott classification). There is a blade embedded in the rock and the edges of the broken off part combine perfectly with the part of the blade that remains inside the stone, excluding the possibility of substitution of the broken off piece. It is a matter of speculation among historians of literature and medievalists if the sword of Montesiepi could be the real-life model for the Arthurian Sword in the Stone, first mentioned in the works of Robert de Boron, in all likelihood written after 1191, more than 10 years after Galgano’s death.

    Notes

    (1) it is interesting to note that the kanji for ‘katana’ is 刀 a character that in Chinese means simply ‘blade’ and refers to any kind of bladed weapon except the sword, for which is used the specific character 劍 (jian).

    (2) Jordanes, The Origin and Deeds of the Goths ch. XXXV quoted from http://www.boudicca.de/jordanes3-e.htm

    (3) Song of Roland quoted from http://www.gutenberg.org/etext/391

    (4) The Montesiepi Chapel is part of the Abbey of Saint Galgano. For photos and info: http://www.sangalgano.org/ENG/index.htm



    Marina Bonomi
    Would you like to support our contributors? As a subscriber, you could use your subscription fee to pay this author for their work, as well as receive lots of extra subscriber perks!



    Fantasy coloring books from Ellen Million Graphics Get a pre-made portrait, ready to go! A 48 hour creative jam for artists An e-zine for fantasy artists and writers A shared world adventure

    Return To EMG-Zine Entrance

    All graphics on these pages are under copyright. Webpage design copyrighted by Ellen Million Graphics. All content copyrighted by the creating artist. If you find anything which is not working properly, please let me know!

    Ellen Million Graphics Main Page

    EMG powered by: a few minions and lots of enchanted search frogs
    --

    Random artwork
    from this issue: